01grad wrote:
I don’t think anything is guaranteed with waiver decisions. There was a kid from Southern Illinois who was playing football in the SEC (Georgia?), had a completely legitimate hardship with a family member that he wanted to transfer back home to the UofI to be closer to. The school he was transferring from supported the move, and Illinois was the closest FBS school to his home. The NCAA denied his waiver and made him sit.
I'm not sure the specifics of the case you're referring to, but maybe the player's case was hurt by the 100 mile rule. Basically, one of the criteria that the NCAA uses for hardship waivers is if you go to a school that's within 100 miles of home. I remember a story about a Virginia Tech football player who was denied a waiver because his home was 105 miles from campus, even though it was the closest FBS school and there was clear medical hardship in his family.
Loyola is less than 100 miles as the crow flies for South Bend so even though it's more than 100 miles driving, Anderson meets the criteria for the waiver. It doesn't make sense to me but it's the NCAA so it doesn't need to make sense.