Just want to post 90-95% agreement with Toledo and all the folks who wrote how much they appreciate the MVC, (most of) the people and fans around the league, the FANTASIC CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT, having great road trips around the Midwest to see our team(s) play, and the really good opportunity we had joining the league.
The one minor point on which I'd disagree is how terrible a bet we were as a replacement to join the MVC. As everyone has mentioned, we were a foothold for the league in the Chicago market, where so many MVC alums live and work. We helped a bit with media, and then when we became good we helped a lot with media. We had a smallish but brand new and right-sized facility for our team in the age of streaming video coverage of every game. We had history-- the '63 National Championship, the '85 Sweet 16, a #1 overall NBA Draft pick, etc. We had probably the best academic profile of any school that has been a member of the MVC in the past 40 years. We were financially healthy and on the upswing in enrollment during a downturn in college enrollment nationwide. We had a commitment to spend and invest in athletics, yes, but we had a history of success, we're in a great market for assistant coaches to work, we have some great athletes in our back yard, and an upgrade in conference affiliation would help us capitalize on those attributes. In short, we were fundamentally and strategically sound in every single measure except recent success in men's basketball.
But going back to where Toledo and I completely agree, the MVC is a great conference. I had hoped there would be a way that the MVC could poach members from the A-10 to vault over them. That would have solved the problem, creating a "little brother" Big East with a range of public and private schools that would rival or best the A-10. But there was no way, apparently, the rest of the MVC teams would upgrade their budgets enough to ensure that they'd be competitive at the national level with P5+BE conference consolidation.
We were told several times by reporters and the league that there's no current offer or interest from the Big East in Dayton or Saint Louis. I hope that holds. If so, we've made the right decision, and a decision that's tough but one we have to make. No disrespect for the MVC, but we've been through that situation before, and
inaction mired us in 20 years of futility and decline as a program.One last comment... one of the things that really worked for us when we went to the MVC was being gracious. As a fanbase, we were
exceedingly gracious to just about everyone and we defended ourselves well, but never attacked. I think that works. It's also funny how most of the people and schools who loved to trash us as a program and a fanbase now either envy us or grudgingly admire the place where we are as a program.