JCT wrote:
Like I've said before, if any one of the four departing frontcourt players (Osborne, O'Leary, Johnson, King) had stayed for this season, this would be a much better looking team with a plausible chance to compete against all but the top three or four teams in the league. Even just having O'Leary, who had the least physical presence among the four, would have provided a lot of cover for Thomas and James. Even just keeping King, the least skilled and experienced of the four, would have offered some fig leaf of defense and a little hesitency on the part of opposing players taking shots near the basket.
I don't care what the internal dynamics were, when you've got four players tasked to perform a similar role all leaving at once, it can't be merely a personality clash or a coincidence. One? Sure... it's understandable. Some people don't get along, and there's probably a bad match that just didn't work out. Two, maybe... but it's starting to seem fishy. Three? Highly improbable, and there's probably something very wrong. Four? Seems impossible for it to be the result of anything but egregious mismanagement. And remember, this is on top of a freshman point guard also bailing out, all the players who were driven out when Moser got here (resulting our worst conference record in the history of the program), and all three assistants leaving at the same time the year before. The list of people asked to leave and who voluntarily left (most of them at great cost to their careers and education) is stunning.
We all knew it was going to be a rough year because of the frontcourt, and Michigan State is a great team, a tough place to play. But MSU's main frontcourt players (Costello, Dawson, and Schilling) going a combined 17 for 25 from the field with 21 rebounds and four blocks, and a 26-2 margin on points in the paint was much worse than imagined from a team that is usually, and in particular this year, led by guards. And Michigan State, at least according to AP polls, is not even the best team we're going to play this year.
That's a problem with Moser's recruiting. I think a big thing he and a lot of coaches preach in their recruiting visits is playing time. Moser had more than usual to offer given he ran off 3/4 of Whitesell's guys and the team wasn't very good in his first year. When players don't get that playing time, that's when they up and leave. If one or two leave, then it's the depth chart, but you're totally right: 4 is too many. Even giving up on King, who would've been a redshirt sophomore this year, so soon is troubling. If Moser wants to run a Villanova, 4 guard offense, then the exodus isn't as bad. We still need exceptional guard play to offset that. That's the bed that Porter made with this roster, so he better find a way to elevate Doyle, White, Turk and Crisman to an outstanding level.